Branden Durst

Branden Durst has held public payroll under three different party identities in two different states. Elected as a Democrat to the Idaho House in 2006 and the Idaho Senate in 2012, he resigned his Senate seat in 2013 after press reporting documented him splitting time between Boise and the Seattle area. He switched party registration to Republican around 2016, lost a Boise School District trustee race in 2018, then took paid roles at the Idaho Family Policy Center and the Idaho Freedom Foundation. He lost the 2022 Republican primary for State Superintendent during the same months that a Thurston County, Washington court issued a temporary protection order against him and his wife, and a King County, Washington judge held him in contempt of court four times. In 2023 he was installed as superintendent of the West Bonner County School District without the state-required certification, fired district employees, was sued, watched the trustees who hired him get recalled by their own community, and resigned after 90 days. He now wants to be First Vice Chair of the Idaho Republican Party.

Inside this dossier:

• The pattern Durst never lost. Socialists demand the public support their lifestyle — paychecks, housing, transportation, legal protection, supermajority job security. Durst’s West Bonner contract demand sheet reads like a Democrat-socialist benefits package: $100K salary, $500 monthly housing allowance, $2,500 travel allowance, wife on district insurance, district-paid legal counsel for his wife, remote-work allowance, supermajority-to-terminate requirement. Different jersey. Same demands.
• The five pivots. Democrat state legislator. Charter-school operator and State Superintendent candidate. West Bonner quasi-superintendent. Idaho Family Policy Center senior policy fellow. IDGOP First Vice Chair candidate. Five different roles. Each one a taxpayer-funded or donor-funded paycheck.
• November 20, 2013 — Senate resignation under residency questions. Per the Idaho Statesman and KTVB, Durst’s Idaho home was observed “empty of furniture.” Senate President Pro Tem Brent Hill told KTVB the residency question “merits investigation.” Durst resigned rather than fight it.
• The 2022 Superintendent run. Lost the Republican primary to Debbie Critchfield with 33.81%. Beck personal $2,555, Regan $1,000, Hoffman $500, Bonneville County GOP $5,000 maximum — the IFF leadership cut him personal checks. Same months: Thurston County temporary protection order, wife charged with misdemeanor injury to child, King County contempt finding, unanimous Senate GOP leadership condemnation after he confronted Sen. Jim Woodward.
• West Bonner: 90 days, no certificate, parental recall. Hired 3-2 by trustees who lacked the votes to override the State Board of Education. State Board executive director Matt Freeman: “no pathway for Mr. Durst to obtain the legally required certification.” Pavey and MacDonald sued the district for unpaid July wages. Two of the three trustees who hired him were recalled by parent petition. He resigned on X: “It may not be entirely fair, but life rarely is.”
• The contract demand the district struck. The original WBCSD contract draft required the district to provide legal counsel for Durst’s wife. The board cut it after audience members yelled about “Durst’s background, particularly allegations of child abuse.” Two trustees walked out of the meeting.
• The Idaho Family Policy Center role. Hired by IFPC President Blaine Conzatti 51 days after losing the 2022 primary. Conzatti described Durst as “an ordained pastor and member of Cloverdale Church of God.” IFPC’s board has documented Doug Wilson connections — Toby Sumpter, Jason Elmore, Israel Waitman — per InvestigateWest, July 22, 2025.
• The IDGOP resolutions push. Verbatim X posts demanding the Idaho Legislature comply with IDGOP grassroots resolutions, attacking U.S. Sen. Jim Risch by name, calling for the resignation of his successor in the Idaho Senate. The “shrink the party to a loyal few” strategy in his own words.

Who he is

Branden John Durst was born in Boise in 1980. He earned a BA in Political Science from Pacific Lutheran University in Washington state in 2002 and a Master of Public Administration from Boise State University in 2014. Per Wikipedia’s Branden Durst entry cross-referenced against Idaho Secretary of State election results, he was elected to the Idaho House of Representatives in District 18A as a Democrat in 2006, re-elected in 2008, lost an Idaho Senate D18 race in 2010, then defeated incumbent Sen. Mitch Toryanski 53.5%–46.5% as a Democrat in 2012.

Per Wikipedia, he switched his party registration from Democratic to Republican around 2016, after running and losing a 2016 Washington Legislative District 29 race as a Democrat. He remarried in Washington state the same year. He lost a 2018 Boise School District trustee race with 4.9% of the vote — last place. He filed for the Idaho Republican primary for State Superintendent of Public Instruction in January 2021. His personal X account is @brandendurst.

Per Idaho Family Policy Center’s own July 7, 2022 announcement of his hire, Durst is “an ordained pastor and member of Cloverdale Church of God.” That fact is on the record from his then-employer.

The pattern Durst never lost: socialist demands in a conservative jersey

Socialists demand the public support their lifestyle. They expect taxpayer-funded paychecks. They expect taxpayer-funded benefits — health insurance for spouses, monthly housing allowances, travel allowances, district-paid transportation, remote-work protections, supermajority job security, legal counsel paid for by someone else. They expect the public to fund the comfortable maintenance of their ideology.

True conservatives reject this. Fiscal responsibility. Free-market capitalism. Skepticism of taxpayer money funding personal lifestyle. Those are the conservative postures. The label on the jersey is not the test. The demand sheet is.

Branden Durst was a Democrat in the Idaho House from 2006 to 2010 and a Democrat in the Idaho Senate from 2012 to 2013. He resigned the Senate ahead of an investigation into whether he actually lived in the district he was supposed to represent. He switched his party registration to Republican around 2016. The label on his jersey changed. The demand pattern did not.

The receipts are documented in the rest of this dossier. The cleanest single piece is the West Bonner contract draft documented in Pivot 3 below. The original draft demanded the West Bonner County School District provide him:

• A $100,000 base salary — top-quartile for a district his size
• A $500 monthly housing allowance in addition to the salary
• A $2,500 travel allowance in addition to the salary
• His wife included in district health insurance
• District-paid legal counsel for his wife — for “any and all demands, claims, suits, actions, and legal proceedings brought against the Superintendent for all non-criminal incidents” — a clause to be read in the chronological context of Cheri Durst’s then-pending Ada County misdemeanor injury-to-child case documented in Pivot 2 below
• A remote-work allowance for a job whose entire point is to be physically present in Priest River
• A supermajority requirement to terminate him

This is not the demand sheet of a Republican who believes government should be small, frugal, and accountable to the taxpayers paying for it. This is the demand sheet of a careerist who expects the public to fund his lifestyle, shield his family, and protect him from termination. The board cut most of the demands after audience members yelled about Durst’s background and two trustees walked out of the meeting — but the demand sheet itself is the receipt. It is what Durst tried to extract from the public before being told no.

The same pattern shows up at every previous and subsequent paycheck stop. The 2022 State Superintendent campaign was a run at a six-figure taxpayer-funded statewide salary. The Idaho Family Policy Center senior policy fellow position is a paid role at a registered nonprofit. The Brabeion Academy charter school launched in 2024 is a publicly-funded charter drawing per-pupil state dollars. The IDGOP First Vice Chair race he is currently running is a party-leadership office whose holder has both stipend potential and political-employment leverage within the IDGOP machinery.

Five pivots. The label on the jersey keeps changing. The hand asking for the taxpayer-funded check is the same hand each time.

Pivot 1 — 2006–2013: Democrat state legislator, residency-questions resignation

Per Kevin Richert’s reporting at Idaho EdNews dated September 9, 2013, Durst — then a sitting state senator on the Senate Education Committee — was living part-time in Washington state where his wife was teaching. Senate President Pro Tem Brent Hill told KTVB the residency question “merits investigation.” Per KTVB’s reporting, KTVB reporters observed his Boise home “looked empty of furniture.”

Durst’s own defense, per KTVB:

The residency questions had been public for over two months before he acted. Per Kevin Richert at the Idaho Statesman, November 20, 2013, he submitted his resignation effective December 1, 2013. He was succeeded by Janie Ward-Engelking, D-Boise — the same legislator he would publicly call on to resign 12 years later under a Republican framing.

He did not fight the residency charge. He vacated.

Pivot 2 — 2014–2022: State Superintendent campaign, IFF money in, court actions out

After leaving the Idaho Senate, Durst worked as an “independent consultant” and then as a mediator at a “child custody and Christian mediation” outfit. Per Durst’s own LinkedIn as catalogued by Peter Greene at curmudgucation, June 27, 2023, he then joined the Idaho Family Policy Center as senior policy fellow and moved on to the Idaho Freedom Foundation as education policy staff. The same Political Potatoes IFF archive cited above frames him as an IFF “go-to favorite” before the 2022 primary.

He filed for the Idaho Republican primary for State Superintendent in January 2021.

What Durst’s IFF paycheck bought: the public-education-defunding pipeline

The Idaho Freedom Foundation that paid Durst’s education-policy paycheck is not a neutral think tank. IFF’s documented institutional agenda is to dismantle Idaho’s public-education system from the inside. Per a July 6, 2023 Idaho EdNews Community Voices piece, the IFF playbook ran in plain sight at the West Bonner County School District:

The same Idaho EdNews piece laid out the pipeline in three steps. Step one: IFF money helped elect far-right candidates Keith Rutledge and Susan Brown to the WBCSD board in November 2021. Step two: the resulting IFF-aligned board majority refused to support a $4.7 million two-year levy intended to cover about a third of the district’s annual operating budget; the levy failed by just over 100 votes on May 15, 2023, putting the district in an extreme financial bind. Step three:

WBCSD patron Nicole Gunning-Butler — quoted in the same Idaho EdNews piece — described IFF’s “relentless attempts to dismantle rural school districts and advance their extreme political and religious agenda.”

Read that sequence again. IFF money elected the board. The IFF-aligned board defunded the district. The same IFF-aligned board hired the IFF’s own education-policy employee — Durst — to run the defunded district. That is not policy advocacy. That is institutional takeover from the inside, executed across roughly twenty months from the 2021 election to the June 2023 hire.

The same institutional-capture model had already been documented at North Idaho College, where IFF board chair Brent Regan’s slate brought a community-college institution “to the brink of ruin” per the same Idaho EdNews piece — covered separately in the Brent Regan dossier.

Durst’s IFF education-policy paycheck — held in the run-up to the 2022 State Superintendent campaign — was a paid role in the institutional-defunding pipeline that landed him at WBCSD a year later. The 2022 Critchfield-vs-Durst Republican Superintendent primary was, in this frame, a fight over whether the IFF’s documented agenda — defund public schools, install IFF-aligned operators — got the keys to the state-level office overseeing 323,000 Idaho schoolchildren. Republican primary voters statewide picked Critchfield. The IFF-aligned WBCSD board picked Durst.

The man pitching himself today as the moral authority on Republican identity drew an IFF paycheck for advancing an agenda whose plain-text goal is the dismantling of public education and whose plain-text method is electing IFF-funded school-board majorities to defund districts and then installing IFF employees to run them. The Idaho Freedom Foundation organizational page on this site documents the broader operational model.

The IFF leadership wrote him checks

Per Idaho EdNews donor reporting at the time of the 2022 superintendent primary cited above (the April 11, 2022 Idaho EdNews donor breakdown; the August 23, 2021 fundraising piece; and the April 25, 2022 “Critchfield continues fundraising dominance” follow-up), the documented IFF-leadership donor signature on Durst’s 2022 committee:

Donor	Amount	IFF role
Doyle Beck	$2,555	IFF Board, East Idaho money
Brent Regan	$1,000	IFF Chairman, KCRCC Chairman
Wayne Hoffman	$500	Then-IFF President
Bonneville County GOP	$5,000	Legal maximum; Beck-controlled county party
Priscilla Giddings campaign	$250	IFF-aligned legislator
Ryan Spoon	$500	McGeachin task force, later ACRCC Vice Chair
Ryan Davidson	$350	IFF-aligned Ada County Commissioner
Hometown Idaho PAC	$250	IFF-aligned endorser

The IFF C-suite — Beck, Regan, Hoffman — collectively cut Durst personal checks totaling $4,055. The Bonneville County GOP $5K to Durst was part of a Beck-controlled slate that drew a state-GOP / Tom Luna bylaws complaint, independently reported by Idaho EdNews. The fundraising profile of the committee — average donation roughly $234, the smallest in the field — combined a grassroots small-dollar register with IFF-leadership max-outs. The pattern is documented across the Doyle Beck dossier and across the IFF donor architecture more broadly.

The money did not just flow in. It flowed back out to the same network’s operational infrastructure. Idaho Sunshine portal records list Durst’s prior campaign activity among the clients of McShane LLC (vendor ID 1008416) — the campaign-management firm run by Bjorn Handeen and documented in IdahoExtremism’s propaganda-network organizational page as the campaign-management vehicle running IFF-network primary challenges across the state. McShane’s current 2026 client list reads as a pure IFF / Idaho Freedom Caucus / Kootenai County Republican Central Committee map — Chad Christensen, Glenneda Zuiderveld, Steve Tanner, James Lamborn, IFC PAC, KCRCC. Durst’s committee paying McShane closes a circle that started with the IFF-leadership donors cutting Durst’s campaign personal checks.

The Woodward confrontation and the unanimous Senate GOP condemnation

On January 19, 2022, after the Idaho Senate Education Committee declined to introduce a parental-rights bill Durst was advocating, Durst confronted Sen. Jim Woodward (R-Sandpoint). Per Idaho Press reporting by Betsy Z. Russell, January 21, 2022, with Idaho Public Television’s Logan Finney and Idaho EdNews’s Kevin Richert contributing, Woodward’s account:

Sen. Janie Ward-Engelking (D-Boise) confirmed she “did see Branden get into Sen. Woodward’s face” and watched Idaho State Police “escort him out.” Idaho State Police were called. Two days later, Idaho Senate Republicans issued a statement signed by every member of Senate GOP leadership describing Durst’s conduct as “egregious” and “unbecoming of anyone, especially a former legislator and current statewide political candidate.” Per the same Idaho Press reporting, Durst was invited to meet with GOP leadership investigating the incident and did not show up.

The Thurston County protection order and the King County contempt finding

Per Ruth Brown’s Idaho Reports / Idaho EdNews reporting, February 18, 2022:

A candidate for Idaho state superintendent of schools is accused of encouraging an act of child abuse, according to a temporary protection order granted this week by a Washington state court.

The court granted an order against Branden Durst and his current wife at the request of Durst’s ex-wife, after a Washington state doctor reported an injured child to Child Protective Services.

Per the same Brown reporting, attributing the allegation directly to the Thurston County petition filed by Durst’s ex-wife Jaime Charles:

According to a copy of the petition filed in Washington, Durst’s ex-wife, Jaime Charles, said Durst’s current wife, Cheri Durst, struck a 14-year-old child with a wooden spoon. In the document, Charles said Branden Durst “not only watched and did nothing to stop it, but he actively encouraged his wife to beat (the child).”

The Thurston County Superior Court issued the temporary protection order “without notice” to Cheri and Branden Durst. Per Brown’s same piece, court commissioner Rebekah Zinn later extended the order through March 16, 2022. Under the order, neither Cheri nor Branden Durst could initiate contact with the children.

Per Brown’s March 8, 2022 follow-up at Idaho Reports / Idaho EdNews:

Branden Durst, candidate for state superintendent of public instruction, will not be criminally charged for accusations made regarding child abuse allegations.

The Ada County Prosecutor’s Office did, however, charge Durst’s wife with misdemeanor injury to child after law enforcement routed them the report for consideration, according to prosecutor’s spokesperson Emily Lowe.

Per the same Brown reporting, Cheri Durst was charged on February 22, 2022 with misdemeanor injury to child under Idaho Code 18-1501, and she entered a not-guilty plea on March 1, 2022. Per Kelcie Moseley-Morris at Idaho Capital Sun / Idaho EdNews, April 26, 2022, Cheri Durst was simultaneously a Republican primary candidate for Ada County coroner.

Durst’s own response to Brown:

Separately, per the same Moseley-Morris piece, a King County, Washington Superior Court judge found Branden Durst in contempt of court on four occasions related to the parenting plan with his ex-wife. The basis for the contempt findings included Durst’s failure to inform the children’s mother that the children had been exposed to COVID-19 while visiting him. He was ordered to pay $4,203 in legal fees and placed on six-month strict-compliance probation. Durst declined to comment to the Capital Sun.

Durst lost the primary

On May 17, 2022, Debbie Critchfield won the Republican primary for State Superintendent with 39.61%. Durst finished second with 33.81%. Sherri Ybarra finished third with 26.58%. He took 60% of the vote in Bonner County.

The IFF leadership had cut him personal checks. The court actions had been entered. The unanimous Senate GOP condemnation was on the public record. Republican primary voters statewide picked someone else.

Pivot 3 — 2023: West Bonner installation, recall, lawsuit, resignation

Per The Spokesman-Review, June 25, 2023 and Coeur d’Alene Press, June 9, 2023, the West Bonner County School District Board of Trustees voted 3-2 on June 9, 2023 to hire Durst as quasi-superintendent. Trustee Keith Rutledge (Board Chair) cast the deciding vote. Trustees Susan Brown and Troy Reinbold joined him. Trustees Margaret Hall and Carlyn Barton voted no.

Durst lacked the state-required superintendent certification.

Herndon’s escort, BCRCC’s backing

Per Bonner County Daily Bee, “Durst selected new WBCSD superintendent,” June 8, 2023 and the September 2023 follow-up at Bonner County Daily Bee, “Extreme right-wing radicals tend to stick together,” September 19, 2023, Sen. Scott Herndon — then chair of the Bonner County Republican Central Committee in addition to his Senate District 1 seat — publicly endorsed Durst, called him a personal friend, and announced the Durst selection on his own X account. The Bonner County Republican Central Committee, which Herndon chaired, formally backed Durst.

Retired 17-year WBCSD music director Barbara Fournier later wrote a letter to the Bonners Ferry Herald dated May 7, 2026 (and cross-published in the Bonner County Daily Bee on May 6, 2026):

The contract demand the district struck

The original WBCSD contract draft for Durst included a provision requiring the district to provide legal counsel for Durst’s wife — for “any and all demands, claims, suits, actions, and legal proceedings brought against the Superintendent for all non-criminal incidents.” The provision lands in context of Cheri Durst’s pending Ada County misdemeanor injury-to-child case documented in Pivot 2 above.

Per Carly Flandro’s Idaho Capital Sun / Idaho EdNews reporting, June 13, 2023, at the June 12, 2023 special meeting to negotiate the contract addendum, audience members yelled at the board “regarding Durst’s background, particularly allegations of child abuse.” Trustees Reinbold and Brown walked out during the meeting. The remaining quorum — Rutledge, Hall, Barton — struck the wife-legal-counsel clause along with a $500 monthly housing allowance, a remote-work allowance, a supermajority-to-terminate requirement, and several other contract demands.

An anchor quote from the meeting, per Flandro:

Durst signed the revised contract on June 28, 2023. His salary was $100,000 with a $2,500 travel allowance and wife included in district insurance.

”I have a different network that’s never been accessed by this district before.”

Per Daniel Walters’s InvestigateWest reporting, July 26, 2023, cross-published at Raw Story, July 27, 2023, Durst fired three district employees within his first month and replaced them with personal picks. Walters quoted Durst directly:

Per the same Walters reporting:

• Melissa Reilly was hired as WBCSD business manager, replacing fired former business manager Steffie Pavey. Durst confirmed the hire on the record with Walters, saying Melissa Reilly’s résumé was “impeccable.” Melissa Reilly is the wife of Dave Reilly — the Idaho operative identified in federal-court discovery in Sines v. Kessler as the Identity Evropa member behind the Discord handle “Davey Crockett,” and later quietly retained by the Idaho Freedom Foundation as a messaging contractor. Walters also documented that Melissa Reilly had earlier provided “nearly $1,000 in in-kind support for Durst during Durst’s failed 2022 campaign for state superintendent” and had let Durst stay at her house once.

• Brandee Pardee (Walters spells it “Brandy Paradee”) was hired as WBCSD board clerk. Per Walters: “for the board clerk position, he picked Brandy Paradee, a leader with ‘Stop Idaho RINOs,’ a group dedicated to rooting out the ‘Republicans in Name Only’ who, its members believe, have infested Idaho politics.” Stop Idaho RINOs is operated by John Heida; see the Heida dossier.

• Walters also documented that during Durst’s failed 2022 superintendent campaign, Durst was the only candidate to receive $900 of in-kind video advertising from “Red Shield Media,” an ad company run by Matthew Colligan — a Charlottesville marcher best known for the catchphrase “Hitler did nothing wrong.” Asked about it, Durst told Walters: “A lot of these people want to stay anonymous.”

That is Durst’s “different network.”

The State Board found no legal pathway

Per Idaho EdNews reporting by Darren Svan, August 3, 2023, WBCSD Board Chair Rutledge wrote a July 7, 2023 letter to State Board of Education executive director Matt Freeman demanding the interim superintendent’s emergency certificate be rescinded — an attempted workaround to clear Durst’s path. State Board executive director Matt Freeman issued a six-page rebuttal:

If an emergency did not exist, it is unclear why the district would have hired (Susan) Luckey to serve as superintendent at its March 17th meeting. … Therefore, no further action will be taken on this matter.

Per KXLY’s Rob King, August 22, 2023, the State Board separately wrote WBCSD that “the hiring of Superintendent Branden Durst possibly violates state law due to his lack of certification.” Per KTVB’s September 25, 2023 coverage of Durst’s resignation, the State Board ultimately ruled there was no legal pathway:

The Pavey + MacDonald lawsuit

Per Idaho Statesman / Spokesman-Review reporting by Nicole Blanchard, August 9, 2023, former WBCSD business manager Steffie Pavey and former payroll employee Shawna MacDonald filed suit against WBCSD on August 7, 2023, seeking unpaid wages for July 2023 work performed after Durst’s mid-July email firings. Pavey was owed approximately 48 hours of unpaid July work; MacDonald approximately 39 hours. Per the same Blanchard reporting, Durst’s defense — that the women had become independent contractors when their employment agreements expired — was characterized as “erroneous” in the suit. [VERIFY case docket and disposition via Bonner County District Court records.]

The recall

On August 29, 2023, parents of West Bonner County School District organized a recall election. Rutledge was ousted by 62.6%. Brown was ousted by 66%. Reinbold, the third pro-Durst vote, was not on the recall ballot. Replacement trustees Sonja “Ann” Yount and Paul Turco were seated October 31, 2023.

The resignation

Per Sadie Dittenber, Idaho Capital Sun / Idaho EdNews, September 25, 2023, Durst announced his resignation via X. Verbatim:

Three months. Three trustees in his column. Two recalled. One lawsuit. No certificate. He resigned ahead of being fired.

Pivot 4 — 2022–2025: Idaho Family Policy Center “senior policy fellow”

Per Kevin Richert at Idaho EdNews, July 7, 2022, Durst joined the Idaho Family Policy Center as senior public policy fellow 51 days after losing the 2022 Republican primary. The hire was a paid, part-time position. IFPC president Blaine Conzatti described Durst in IFPC’s own July 7, 2022 hire announcement as “an ordained pastor and member of Cloverdale Church of God.”

IFPC’s documented Christian-nationalist ties

Per Brigham Tomco at the Deseret News, July 24, 2025, Conzatti told the Deseret News on the record that he would not oppose declaring Idaho a “Christian state” and implementing religious tests for public office. Per the same reporting, Conzatti “does draw a line between ‘historic Christianity,’ based on the Apostles’ and Nicene Creeds, and the faith of Latter-day Saints” — explicitly excluding LDS members from his definition of Christian.

Per Daniel Walters at InvestigateWest, July 22, 2025, IFPC’s board has documented Doug Wilson connections. Walters reported:

Nearly two-thirds of the policy center’s board have clear connections to Wilson. There’s Toby Sumpter who was Wilson’s assistant pastor; Jason Elmore, a parish elder at Wilson’s church, and Israel Waitman who sits on the board of the New Saint Andrews, the Christian college Wilson founded.

Per the same Walters reporting, Wilson “is also Conzatti’s personal friend, giving him strategic advice and fundraising help, and has been a guest speaker at the policy center’s Biblical Activism Bootcamp.” Conzatti on the record to Walters:

Doug Wilson holds no formal governance role at IFPC. The documented organizational ties are board overlap, recurring-speaker appearances at IFPC events, the personal-friendship description by Conzatti, and fundraising help — per Walters, on the record with the IFPC president.

Durst’s “litmus test” op-ed

Per Branden Durst’s own July 25, 2024 op-ed in Idaho EdNews Community Voices, under the byline “Head of School of Sport at Brabeion Academy and former Idaho senator and representative”:

The same op-ed proposes both an ESA “that can rollover” and a fully refundable tax credit of “at least $5,000,” and warns that “if Governor Little and Superintendent Critchfield continue to obstruct progress and threaten a veto, legislators should not shy away from confrontation.” The taxpayer-funded private and religious tuition push — Durst’s policy register, in his own words — uses the explicit “litmus test” frame.

Pivot 5 — 2025–2026: Senate D11 filing, withdrawal, IDGOP First Vice Chair race

The Senate D11 filing and withdrawal

Per Gem State Chronicle’s October 2025 release, Durst filed for the Republican primary in Idaho Senate District 11 (Caldwell), challenging incumbent Sen. Chris Trakel — an IFF-aligned senator already documented in the Trakel dossier. Durst registered “Friends of Durst for Idaho” with the Idaho Secretary of State on January 16, 2026 and self-loaned $35,000 — the entire opening capital base of the committee.

Thirty-three days later, he withdrew. Per KTVB, February 18, 2026 and Idaho EdNews, Durst cited his Brabeion Academy charter school launch and Senate “status quo.” The committee’s total third-party contributions over the run were essentially zero. The committee was a vehicle for his own loan, paid back to himself.

The IDGOP First Vice Chair candidacy

Per Gem State Chronicle, June 2026, Durst is now running for First Vice Chair of the Idaho Republican Party — an intra-party leadership role decided at the IDGOP State Convention rather than at the ballot box. He is running alongside IDGOP Chair Dorothy Moon’s bid for a third Chair term. Their platform centers on stopping “crossover voting” in Republican primaries.

The pivot is exact: after Idaho voters declined him in 2010 (Senate D18), 2018 (Boise School Board), 2022 (State Superintendent), and 2026 (he withdrew from Senate D11 rather than face Trakel) — Durst is now seeking a party office that voters do not choose.

What he wants to do with it: shrink the party

Durst’s own X record documents the strategy. On January 3, 2026 (status 2007473769405616148):

The strategy applies as far up as U.S. Senate. November 13, 2024 (status 1856561556601090135) — 487 likes, 16,500 views:

The same purity-enforcement frame applied to a sitting U.S. Senator from his own party. The day after, Durst followed up (November 13, 2024, status 1856769057032450142): “As expected @SenatorRisch does’t give a damn about what the #idgop grassroots thinks. The question is, can we teach him a lesson?”

The same frame applied to his own Senate-seat successor. April 3, 2026 (status 2040106136364527864) — 1,207 likes, 40,000 views, his highest-engagement attack post:

The same purity-enforcement frame applied across the aisle as a structural correction of his own 2013 vacancy.

The pattern lands on his own former employer. On the same January 3, 2026 thread, Durst attacked Dustin Hurst — IFF strategist, current PUP Senior Director of Development, IFPAC Treasurer (status 2007551254038253803):

The dossier reader can take Durst’s word for it: the man Durst is now publicly calling unreliable is one of the central operators of the network that handed Durst his IFF education-policy paycheck.

The IDGOP First Vice Chair race is the closed-tent strategy in operation. Whether or not the closed-primary resolutions get formally adopted in convention, the X record above documents the public posture Durst would bring to the office.

The composite picture

Five pivots. Five paychecks or donor-funded perches. Each one ends in either a documented voter rejection, a court action, an institutional condemnation, or a quiet exit. The receipts in this dossier are not interpretive. They are court orders, named-reporter coverage, sworn legislative-leadership statements, Durst’s own filings, and Durst’s own X posts.

• A Democrat state senator who resigned ahead of an investigation that Senate President Pro Tem Brent Hill said his residency “merits.”
• A State Superintendent candidate running for the office that oversees 323,000 Idaho schoolchildren during the same months a Thurston County court issued a protection order against him and his wife, the Ada County prosecutor declined to charge him, his wife was charged with misdemeanor injury to child, and a King County judge found him in contempt of court four times.
• A quasi-superintendent installed 3-2 by trustees without the state-required certification, who fired employees, drew a wage-claim lawsuit, watched two of his three trustees recalled by their own community by 62.6% and 66%, then resigned ahead of being fired.
• An ordained pastor working for an organization whose board has documented ties to a Christian-nationalist pastor whose stated political project is to declare Idaho a “Christian state” and reinstate religious tests for public office that explicitly exclude Latter-day Saints.
• An aspiring party officer publicly attacking U.S. Sen. Jim Risch by name, his own state-Senate-seat successor by name, and his own former employer by name — running on a platform of stopping crossover voting and tightening resolution-enforcement against any Republican who deviates from grassroots-resolution language.

Durst’s career is a sequence of pivots through different ideological jerseys. The pivots themselves change. The pattern doesn’t.

Why Idaho Republicans should care

Idaho is a closed-primary state in which the Republican primary is the consequential election in most legislative districts. Whoever runs the Idaho Republican Party from the inside controls the rules of that election: who counts as a Republican for purposes of voting in the primary, what kinds of crossover protections exist, how grassroots resolutions move from convention floor into legislative-enforcement pressure on sitting members. The position of First Vice Chair is an internal-party seat that shapes those rules.

The candidate seeking that seat already publicly attacks sitting Republican U.S. Senators by name for not following IDGOP-grassroots resolutions, publicly attacks his own state-Senate-seat successor by name, publicly attacks the current PUP / IFPAC leadership of the IFF network that paid his earlier salary, and publicly defended the West Bonner trustees against the parents who recalled them at 62.6% and 66% margins. The closed-tent strategy is not a future possibility — it is documented in his own X posts.

The party-enforcement model is the CCP model

Durst’s stated platform for First Vice Chair is a party-enforcement office. He wants to control who counts as a Republican. Who gets to run for office on the Republican line. Who gets to vote in a Republican primary. Which sitting Republican legislators get punished by their own party machinery for not toeing the resolution-enforcement line. He has stated each of these objectives in his own published words.

That is not the American constitutional model of a political party. The American model treats the political party as a voluntary association of voters who choose, every cycle, to belong to the party for whatever reasons they choose. The party machinery exists to serve those voters, not to discipline them. Resolutions adopted at conventions reflect the views of the activists who attend conventions; they are not statutes that obligate sitting legislators on penalty of party-machinery sanction.

The model Durst is running on — a small central committee dictating who can run, who can vote, who counts as a Republican; tight ideological loyalty tests at the candidate-filing layer; purges of sitting members who deviate from the resolution-enforcement line — is the Chinese Communist Party model. Centralized party committee. Tight ideological filtering of who is allowed to run. Public discipline of any member who fails the loyalty test. Mao would recognize the structure. Importing it into the Idaho Republican Party is not American conservatism. It is a former-Democrat’s idea of party hygiene wearing a Republican jersey.

The Colorado warning

This is what happened in Colorado. The Republican Party there allowed its extremists to take control of its internal machinery. They pushed out the broad-tent Republicans who actually win general elections. Voters who could no longer find a home in the shrunken Republican Party started identifying as unaffiliated. Democrats — eventually — figured out what was happening, organized accordingly, and converted the state. Colorado was the conservative West a generation ago. Today it is a reliably blue state with a Democratic governor, Democratic legislative supermajorities, and a Democratic congressional delegation. The Republican Party in Colorado shrank its own tent until there was no tent left to shrink.

Idaho is Republican today because the Republican Party has been the broad tent Idahoans go to for their politics. Branden Durst is running for the office that decides whether that tent stays broad. If Idaho Republican delegates hand him the keys to the First Vice Chair seat and let him implement the platform he is publicly running on — shrink the rolls, enforce resolution-compliance against sitting members, fight crossover voting, purge the “Republicans in Name Only” — the Colorado outcome is the predictable destination. Not in one cycle. Not in two. But the trajectory is the same.

The voters Durst would push out are not Democrats. They are conservative Idahoans who don’t pass his ideological purity test. They will leave the Republican Party. They will register unaffiliated. They will be available to a Democratic Party organized to compete for them.

What the delegates are actually choosing

Idaho Republican delegates and PCOs will be the people who decide at the 2026 State Convention whether Branden Durst gets to set the rules of the next primary. The choice is not abstract. It is the choice between a broad-tent Republican Party that continues to win Idaho elections and a centralized-enforcement model — imported by a former Democrat who has never shed the Democrat-socialist demand pattern — that will eventually hand Idaho to the Democrats.

This dossier exists so that choice can be made on the public record.

Connected pages

• Scott Herndon dossier, the senator who escorted Durst into Priest River and whose Bonner County Republican Central Committee formally backed the installation
• Dave Reilly dossier, the operative whose wife Durst hired as WBCSD business manager and whose Idaho Tribune attribution chain Durst is the named inside source on
• Dustin Hurst dossier, the IFF / PUP / IFPAC operative Durst now publicly attacks as unreliable
• Greg Pruett dossier, propaganda-network operator inside the same IFF orbit
• Chris Trakel dossier, the IFF-aligned incumbent senator Durst filed against and then withdrew from challenging
• John Heida dossier, operator of Stop Idaho RINOs, the organization Durst hired Brandee Pardee out of for the WBCSD board-clerk role
• Idaho Freedom Foundation organization page, Durst’s former employer
• Propaganda network organization page, the messaging infrastructure documented in the Reilly attribution chain Durst sourced

Methodology

Every claim in this dossier links to a primary source or to Tier 2 named-reporter coverage. The five reporters who anchor the load-bearing chronology are: Kevin Richert (Idaho EdNews, Idaho Statesman), Ruth Brown (Idaho Reports / Idaho EdNews), Kelcie Moseley-Morris (Idaho Capital Sun), Daniel Walters (InvestigateWest / Washington State Standard / Coeur d’Alene Press), and Sadie Dittenber (Idaho Capital Sun / Idaho EdNews). Court actions are cited to the issuing courts: Thurston County Superior Court (Washington), King County Superior Court (Washington), Ada County District Court (Idaho). Campaign-finance figures are pulled from Idaho Secretary of State Sunshine and from Idaho EdNews’s contemporaneous reporting of itemized contributions to the 2022 superintendent committee. Durst’s X posts are quoted verbatim with direct status URLs.

[Not authorized by any candidate or candidate’s committee. All citations link to primary sources or Tier-2 credible media.]

Have evidence?

If you have direct documents, recordings, or firsthand information related to anything on this page — campaign-finance records from the 2022 Durst for Superintendent committee, WBCSD-area material from the June–September 2023 window, Ada County court records on the Cheri Durst misdemeanor disposition, or Bonner County District Court records on the Pavey + MacDonald lawsuit — submit a tip.